Worse than Flat-Funding?
I’m not 100% sure what to make of this just yet, but according to the specific numbers in the House budget plan (H5300, Article 21, substitute A), many Rhode Island communities will get less education aid, in terms of absolute dollars, than they did last year. Here are exact numbers from the text of the bill…
| Community | Education Aid FY 2007 | Education Aid FY 2008 (prop.) | Change From 2007 to 2008 |
| Barrington | $2,599,526 | $2,599,526 | $0 |
| Bristol-Warren | $20,498,190 | $20,228,190 | -$270,000 |
| Burrillville | $13,779,743 | $13,539,743 | -$240,000 |
| Charlestown | $2,002,838 | $2,002,838 | $0 |
| Central Falls | $43,313,036 | $43,313,036 | $0 |
| Chariho | $398,334 | $398,334 | $0 |
| Coventry | $20,075,081 | $19,955,081 | -$120,000 |
| Cranston | $35,580,911 | $35,460,911 | -$120,000 |
| Cumberland | $13,257,009 | $13,257,009 | $0 |
| East Greenwich | $1,949,761 | $1,844,761 | -$105,000 |
| East Providence | $26,762,254 | $26,132,254 | -$630,000 |
| Exeter-West Greenwich | $7,661,019 | $7,256,019 | -$405,000 |
| Foster | $1,416,463 | $1,416,463 | $0 |
| Foster-Glocester | $5,729,861 | $5,729,861 | $0 |
| Glocester | $3,213,847 | $3,213,847 | $0 |
| Hopkinton | $6,241,352 | $6,241,352 | $0 |
| Jamestown | $531,908 | $531,908 | $0 |
| Johnston | $10,915,364 | $10,615,364 | -$300,000 |
| Lincoln | $7,403,268 | $7,283,268 | -$120,000 |
| Little Compton | $368,810 | $368,810 | $0 |
| Middletown | $10,497,116 | $10,077,116 | -$420,000 |
| Narragansett | $1,897,159 | $1,897,159 | $0 |
| Newport | $11,796,080 | $11,316,080 | -$480,000 |
| New Shoreham | $106,345 | $106,345 | $0 |
| North Kingstown | $11,986,005 | $11,986,005 | $0 |
| North Providence | $13,232,872 | $13,142,872 | -$90,000 |
| North Smithfield | $4,834,237 | $4,714,237 | -$120,000 |
| Pawtucket | $66,858,559 | $66,003,559 | -$855,000 |
| Portsmouth | $6,250,042 | $6,130,042 | -$120,000 |
| Providence | $193,974,756 | $190,824,756 | -$3,150,000 |
| Richmond | $6,188,615 | $6,188,615 | $0 |
| Scituate | $3,407,183 | $3,407,183 | $0 |
| Smithfield | $5,668,568 | $5,428,568 | -$240,000 |
| South Kingstown | $10,428,698 | $10,173,698 | -$255,000 |
| Tiverton | $5,932,058 | $5,932,058 | $0 |
| Warwick | $37,626,000 | $37,266,000 | -$360,000 |
| Westerly | $6,843,077 | $6,843,077 | $0 |
| West Warwick | $20,440,547 | $20,440,547 | $0 |
| Woonsocket | $47,616,613 | $47,016,613 | -$600,000 |
Anybody have any idea what’s happening here?
No, but great catch, Andrew. Maybe flat funding is a new euphemism for reduction.
It seems that adding back education related group home aid, calculated on a per bed basis and previously aggregated in state aid to education figures, will likely bring the figures back to even.
Hmmmmm,
I think you may be half-right. I think the changes do relate to the group-home provisions of education aid.
However, I’m not sure that these cuts are compensated for elsewhere in the budget. I think these numbers reflect true cuts, e.g. East Providence will have $630,000 less in state aid to fund the total package of education and group home programs they funded last year. If I’ve misinterpreting this, I welcome someone pointing out the relevant section of the budget legislation to me.
(The changes in Article 21 of H5300A involving group-home funding seem to relate mostly to determining how mid-year changes in the number of group-home beds in a community will be assessed.)
And I’m starting to see the possibility of a cynical dimension to this too. Is the legislature getting retting ready to tell people, see, if we had a “funding formula”, we couldn’t have made those cuts in group-home aid, because your education aid would have been a legally mandated entitlement?
You found the relevant section. As you noted, if you go to the Sub A of Budget Article 21, start reading from the revisions starting about the middle of page 14 – note that in addition to allowing for mid-year adjustments, full funding for group home education costs is specified. Then, check the Dept of Ed’s website for the allocations made last year, and you will see that the amounts for group homes were backed out of the revised education aid figures.
I am cynical on the opposite side of the formula issue – there will be no funding formula without funding, because of the potential litigation that could follow an unfunded formula.
This is interesting. So local aid to group homes was always under the category of education aid? But this year, they backed it out of the education category? Was there some nefarious (or other) reason they did this?
This is going to run on a bit, but I want to be specific about the changes we’re discussing.
Here’s the new text added to section 16-64-1.1 of Rhode Island law by H5300A, Article 21.
To section (b)(1), a notification requirement with no change in funding…
To section (b)(3), a specific expenditure mandate, with no funding mechanism…
A brand new section (b)(4) that spells out rules for dealing with the funding ramifications when the number of beds in a community changes in mid-year…
That’s everything new.
All of the provisions about the state giving aid to communities based on the existing number of group home beds is already written into law, specifically, section (b)(3)…
But (except for the Bradley hospital provision) the above clause is not being changed this year, at least by Article 21, to offset the cuts being made in general education aid.
Unless there’s an offset in another article, it looks to me as if the legislature is robbing Peter (general education aid) to pay Paul (group home funding), resulting in a true funding cut for the towns involved.
Again, I welcome corrections to any misinterpretation I may be making here.