Justin Katz

Toward a More Optimistic Pessimism

By Justin Katz | February 5, 2011 |

I agree with R. R. Reno’s assessment, presented in his review of The Uses of Pessimism: And the Danger of False Hope, by Roger Scruton (non-subscribers can try here): Scruton observes that “the belief that human beings can either foresee the future or control it to their own advantage ought not to have survived an…

Checking Out of the Race

By Justin Katz | February 4, 2011 |

The Lonely Conservative (being from New York state) has posted an email from an online acquaintance that voices a sentiment with which increasing numbers of us are surely familiar: And I watch countless news stories about people who are criminals (illegal aliens, felons) liars, cheats, or just stupid getting help with their mortgage loans because…

Opening the Gateway

By Justin Katz | February 4, 2011 |

Drug legalization isn’t an issue about which I’m passionate; when it comes to marijuana, I’m pretty much ambivalent. The fact that Froma Harrop supports legalization does make me wonder whether the opposite view might be wiser. In that regard, Providence College history professor Richard Grace makes some reasonable points: One wonders whether the real goal…

The Godlessness of the Gaps

By Justin Katz | February 3, 2011 |

Philosophy Professor John Haldane adds his own commentary to the list addressing Stephen Hawking’s lately released The Grand Design. If the subject catches your interest, you should certainly read the whole essay, but one point attracted my attention in particular: [The authors] then go on to note, however, that “it is not only the peculiar…

One Man’s Left-of-Center Is Another Man’s Far Left

By Justin Katz | February 3, 2011 |

Really, what could we say about RI House Speaker Gordon Fox’s appointment of Rep. Edith Ajello as Chairwoman of the Judiciary Committee that would surprise anybody or that would have any effect on anybody’s opinion? The state’s political leadership is zagging when it needs to zig, and she’s a strong indication of it. The labels…

When One Group’s Ascendency Must Prevent Another’s

By Justin Katz | February 3, 2011 |

It’s fascinating to hear people who wish to radically alter the law and culture by any means necessary and silence their opposition attempt to explain why the other side is the home of oppression and closed mindedness. One specimen of the genre, oddly not apparently online, comes courtesy David Adams Murphy. After introducing his subject…

How a Bill Gets a Hearing

By Justin Katz | February 3, 2011 |

Matt gave Andrew some running room, on last night’s Matt Allen Show, to explain his findings on how the General Assembly can be made to operate a bit more like a real legislature. Stream by clicking here, or download it. Imagine how much more of this sort of thing we could do if we didn’t…

Watching the Intellectual Weight

By Justin Katz | February 2, 2011 |

Juslia Steiny deployed an interesting simile, a couple of columns ago, that serves the opposite point than that which she makes: However, standardized-test scores in isolation, alongside no other measures, are a hurtful, immoral misuse of good information. Parents value many features of a school as much, if not more than, achievement. Along with their…

A Controlled Use for Weapons

By Justin Katz | February 2, 2011 |

Elbridge Colby has an interesting article in First Things (see here if you’re not a subscriber) addressing the ability of nuclear weapons to fit within the just war tradition. One point worth emphasizing comes to mind upon reading his summation of the “nay” argument (with which he disagrees): The argument proffered by the churchmen is…

Seems Folks Argued This All Along…

By Justin Katz | February 2, 2011 |

This point was made so early in debate over the federal healthcare overhaul — before the Democrats rammed it into law despite every negative signal from the American people — that it’s difficult to believe that anybody still believes the opposite. Still, it’s worth noting its restatement: Two of the central promises of President Barack…

Show your support for Anchor Rising with a 25-cent-per-day subscription.