Marriage & Family

Liberty Isn’t Their Concern

By Justin Katz | July 25, 2010 |

Somehow the headline “Voicing their views” feels a bit discordant over an article that includes this detail: Speakers from the New Jersey-based National Organization for Marriage seemed startled as they were encircled by counter-protesters who yelled, sang and waved the rainbow flag associated with the gay-pride movement. Then, as some 170 protesters — most wearing…

Marriage Is What We Make It

By Justin Katz | July 22, 2010 |

Commenter Rasputin scoffs at my suggestion that, as men become less useful as economic partners and less attractive as mates, heterosexual women will begin marrying each other. You can call the idea crazy, but remember that you did so when the New York Times or Dateline runs a story about the trend of “BFF second…

Getting Past the Circular Fiat

By Justin Katz | July 14, 2010 |

Accusations of bigotry notwithstanding, I’ve long maintained that what drew me into the same-sex marriage debate about a decade ago was the intriguing and telling argument driving the innovation. The point is perhaps best summed in a passage from Andrew Sullivan’s Virtually Normal, which I quoted in a post some years ago: Some might argue…

Congress Lacks a Constitutionally Granted Power to Define Marriage, † Œ Ø ¿

By Justin Katz | July 10, 2010 |

Andrew’s #5 makes me wonder whether he isn’t too enamored of the opportunity to oppose lefitsts in the course of supporting a liberal judicial ruling. I’ll admit that I, too, find it very interesting that my reasons for disagreeing with Judge Tauro’s rulings (as I understand them) ought to ally me with a variety of…

Re: Congress Lacks a Constitutionally Granted Power to Define Marriage

By Justin Katz | July 10, 2010 |

As Andrew’s post on Judge Tauro’s ruling concerning the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) proves, conservatives will find a great deal of intellectual meat in the development — setting principles of federalism against a traditional understanding of marriage. I’ll have more to say on the issue in days to come, but for the moment, discussion…

Massachusetts District Court Says that Congress Lacks a Constitutionally Granted Power to Define Marriage

By Carroll Andrew Morse | July 9, 2010 |

In a decision issued yesterday, the Federal District Court for Massachusetts overturned a portion of the Federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) for reasons including the violation of the Tenth Amendment and Congress lacking an enumerated basis for defining marriage, in the case of Massachusetts v. Department of Health and Human Services. Section 3 of…

Proving Sex Ed Policies a Failure

By Justin Katz | June 16, 2010 |

One hears, from time to time, that abstinence only sex education has been proven to be a failure. Not only is the proof arguably incorrect, but the entire premise misses the mark. Abstinence education hardly enjoyed meager implementation, let alone the pervasive reinforcement that would be necessary for society-wide effect. But I do wonder what…

UPDATED: Doggedly Raising the Contraceptive Point

By Justin Katz | June 5, 2010 |

Frankly, the comments to my post on contraception were about what I expected. The Pill, condoms, and their less common company are secular sacraments, and people are very reluctant to place them on the table for skeptical scrutiny. (It might… or might not… go too far to imply an underlying sense of prickliness about their…

Contraception and Distortion of a Market

By Justin Katz | June 3, 2010 |

Timothy Reichert had a very interesting analysis in the May issue of First Things applying economic and social science principles to the effect of the Pill on American relationships. (Unfortunately, the magazine appears to be having long-term technical difficulties with its firewall, so even a subscription might not enable access.) Here’s the premise with which…

How the Accommodating Institution Declines

By Justin Katz | May 2, 2010 |

Apparently, in fields that debate such things, there’s been an attempt to apply economic principles to explain the ebbs and flows of attendance in different churches. John Lamont does some difference splitting and paints a persuasive picture (subscription required). Because “the rewards of religion are supernatural and, therefore, unseen,” the healthy religion, he explains, requires…

Show your support for Anchor Rising with a 25-cent-per-day subscription.